08 October 2012

Total Depravity, Me, and My Grandpa

Life is hectic and busy this week, leaving me without much time for original posting, so this is a repost. I wrote this almost exactly three years ago (10/06/2009) and this just might be the best thing I have ever written. It is certainly one thing that means very much to me. And reading back through it now it is hard not to miss the young man who wrote it:


My grandpa died last Sunday in a hospice bed in Topeka. Clara and I were out in Kansas at the time. Grandpa Leon had battled throat cancer for over 7 years and in the last month it had turned hopelessly bad. We rounded up the family and were to assemble in Kansas to say our goodbyes. The doctor was ambiguous, as is their custom, unable to tell us with any specificity when death might come. So we flew out from El Paso on the Friday before the Sunday and made it to the care center just in time, as the storybook dictates. He hugged and kissed us and smiled at us and surely knew that we were there. That night his entire family stood around his bed and we cried and told him goodbye and told him as well that it was alright to let go. He held on for another 36 hours or so after that point. Sunday morning, sometime while my mom was in the shower and Clara and I were out on a run and my dad was having a cup of coffee and enjoying a crisp Kansas morning on the cusp of fall, my uncle left the room at the hospice so that the attending nurses could rotate my grandpa in his bed and when they let him back into the room his and my mom’s father and Tyler and me’s grandpa was dead. Just like that; in the blink of an eye.

For those of you unfamiliar I have had a complicated relationship with my maternal grandfather. It is not that he wasn’t a good grandpa; matter of fact that may have been what he was best at. But it is not an altogether uncommon human experience to revere and love someone in your childhood and then to find out at some later point that they are a sinner beyond what you imagined; beyond what your own goodness and righteousness can tolerate. Such was my experience with my grandpa, and though I won’t belabor you with his sins (which is something akin to gossip in this setting), allow me to say that there was partial justification for the disdain I held him in for the past 10-12 years. Partial, mind you.

The last post in this blog was on the doctrine of total depravity, the much maligned tenet of Calvinistic Christianity which says, in layman’s terms, we all suck. This is similar to the doctrine of original sin which says that when Adam fell he dragged down all of creation with him and to this day we are born into sin and not with a blank slate. Augustine popularized the doctrine and Chesterton quipped that it was the single doctrine backed with modern day empirical proof. I myself did not witness the virgin birth or the resurrection, but I do witness human depravity and sin every day. Empirical provability aside, there is nothing more contrarian to the modern mind than this idea that we begin life already dead. This world and its afternoon talk shows are full of people telling us we have an inner goodness and if we follow the six, seven, or eight simple steps outlined in their book we can tap into our own goodness and live at peace with all people. And also get rich. And this is an understandable impulse for the world, but it is bad for the Church and, my goodness, how this has infected the Church as well. Here I refer not only to the simple punching bag of a guy like Joel Osteen whose prosperity gospel is more full of holes than the term paper of an undergraduate philosophy student, but to the more benign form that we find in most Christian churches. There is everywhere a tendency to downplay sin. In order to make Christianity more palatable to the masses we can’t be condemning them with guilt for their sins and then telling them the good news about Jesus. Let’s skip instead straight to the good news: Hey, Jesus died for you. OK, well why? Umm, because you, well, you know, you broke some of the Ten Commandments and lied to your parents when you were a kid. So Jesus had to die for that? Yeah, it is kind of weird, but when you are a Christian you will feel peace that passes all understanding and get to live forever with God. And if I don’t become a Christian? Umm, well, the Bible talks about this place called hell. God will send me to hell for breaking commandments and lying to my parents? Yes, but he doesn’t want to so pray this prayer and you’re in!

I often digress into silly conversations in order to prove a point. In that rendering of the gospel there is nothing to be saved from, really. There is shuddered mention of sin and hell, but it makes God seem like an angry, moody teenager for condemning sin and sending people to hell. There is no notion of righteous wrath and vindication, of man’s deplorable condition in relation to God, of our utter inability to do anything on our own, or of God’s glory and grace in sending Jesus as our propitiation.

And this was my functional gospel for much of my life. Sure I was a sinner, but I wasn’t a bad sinner and now I am pretty good. I was mature for my age, responsible, kept jobs, and impressed adults; I mostly avoided illicit substances and was a good friend to people that I liked. Sure I swore and lusted and didn’t hang out with people who I thought weren’t cool, but I never did anything bad. I surely wasn’t bad in my core, or dead in my sins and transgressions. I was presented the opportunity to be good and for the most part took it and therefore I was better than people who chose otherwise. Now in a convoluted and limited sense this is true. We ought to choose Lincoln’s “better angels” over our inner devils more often than not, but the mistake we make is to attribute this to internal righteousness; it is no such thing. Consciousness of sin, and right and wrong; yes. But right-standing in front of God; not even close.

It is not until we accept our own badness, our own deadness, our own inability to do anything apart from grace received by the gift of faith that we will ever view our fellow man in the proper context and with the proper amount of humility and grace. And this truth hit me like a ten-pound hammer a few weeks ago, in the shower of all places. My mom had booked our plane tickets back to Kansas and I was imagining what I would say to my grandpa, the man I reviled above all other men in my life. The force of my own sin and ugliness was laid on me in that moment and the disrespect and evilness which existed in my heart was exposed as the indulgent self-righteousness of a punk kid. I was disgusted and heartbroken and cried as I stood there and began speaking the words that I wanted to say to him; words for once of grace and truth.

But life, as I have found, is not always as poetic as I wish it would be. I mentioned earlier when we got to grandpa’s room at the hospice house he smiled and kissed and hugged and knew we were there, but those were the limits of his power for his remaining time on earth. He died without having another conversation, the one I intended to have with him included. And I knew as I stood and cried at the foot of his bed later that night that I would never get that chance; that the imagined conversation in all of its beauty and grace would remain as so many other beautiful things in my life- merely a good intention.

And so it fell for me to say them for the first time, and on a one-way street, as I gave the eulogy at his funeral last week. I told the audience assembled that God’s grace had been ever-present in my grandpa’s life and even though he felt like he had a hard lot God had given him many wonderful things. He had given him a wife who remained faithful, despite hardships, for 48 years; a daughter who turned out to be a saint and whose life was spared by her Redeemer two years before; a son who had wrestled his own demons and become quite the man and quite the son; grandkids who grew up strong and happy and loved. He had a horrendous battle with cancer, but alongside of it the entire time was very uncommon grace.

And then I told the audience that I had hated my grandpa in my heart for a lot of my life. I told them I was far harder on him than I had the right to be; far harder than was fair. I told them that my goodness and my grandpa’s sins both landed us in the same place apart from the grace of God. I told them that I didn’t know whether or not my grandpa was in heaven, but that he was just the type of person my God loves to save; a man who has seen the face of his own evil and can lay no claims to his own goodness. I told them; but I never told him.

No comments:

Post a Comment